‘Conversations with friends’ is not loud enough

Perhaps the Irish author sally rooney chose the rather generic title conversations with friends for his first novel because a more suitable one, something like The Peculiarities of Being an Outcast, either The Annoyances of being an outcast?- would be a bit too much on the nose. The story from Rooney’s college years (and the new series adaptation, premiering May 15 on Hulu) is about a shy, withdrawn guy with a slow-moving storm inside of her. There are conversations with friends (and potential lovers and mentors), but the biggest dialogue that occurs is internal.

The series is about Frances, 21 years old (recently arrived alison oliver), a quiet, ambitious and curious student from Dublin who has recently separated from Bobbi (sasha lane), now demoted (or, some might argue, promoted) to best friend. Bobbi and Frances have a spoken word poetry act that they perform at local coffee shops and the like, which brings them to the attention of an older, established writer, Melissa (Jemima Kirke), and her laconic actor husband, Nick (joe alywn). It’s not clear why these decrepit thirty-somethings would want to spend time with this pair of newbies, except that something about Frances and Bobbi’s youth must be a distraction from Melissa and Nick’s complex adult concerns.

Inevitably, some tensions arise, mainly because Frances and Nick enter into an affair that quickly consumes all of Frances’s waking thoughts. It’s not an obsession, actually, that would suggest something one-sided, which it definitely isn’t. But Frances loses sight of her old self as she plunges headlong into a period of sexual and emotional exploration, wondering if she has cracked the code of this taciturn older man or if she is deluding herself terribly. Maybe it’s both.

The series was adapted by alice birch and much of it is run by Lenny Abramsonwho worked on the 2020 Hulu adaptation of Rooney’s second novel, Normal people. His house style is a kind of giddy, pessimistic frankness. The color palette is off; the music comes more as punctuation than underlining; central performances are restrained almost to the point of silence. That is especially true of conversationswith his two bare lovers taking up so much space.

For perhaps too much of the series’ twelve-episode run, the silence at its center proves frustrating. Frances is so recessive that she’s hardly a character. You want someone, maybe Bobbi, to shake her by the shoulders and plead with her to wake up from her. (Eventually, she does.) Nick is so forced and closed off that it’s hard to believe him as an actor. It’s great that these two mimes met, but they’re not very convincing to watch.

Eventually, however, the true intent of Rooney’s lo-fi saga is revealed. It turns out that Frances is undergoing quite a profound evolution, going through a characteristic crucible of growth. The series chronicles Frances’s hard-won realization, one shared by many of us who have spent a lot of time in our heads, that she does, in fact, move through the world with consequences. What she imagines to be mere passive observation has an effect on what she is witnessing. That can be a daunting thing to comprehend for someone who believes she’s invisible, or at least downplays her importance in a given ecosystem.

There is an egoism in that supposition, an arrogance too. Frances has a keen intellect and political conviction that occasionally attacks most of the well-meaning people in her orbit. Can her shyness be attributed to a deep, perhaps even unconscious, belief that she is smarter than everyone else? Of course. A little, anyway. conversations with friends it is sharp enough to criticize its protagonist. But Frances also intensely doubts herself: she worries about her appearance, her social prowess, her inability to shine like Bobbi and Melissa do, to navigate the world with such ease.

She is wrong about that facility, of course. And she is wrong to think that she can push the world without it responding to her touch. This is a subtle thing to try to illustrate outside of a novel’s internal monologue, but the series eventually gets there. That’s due to the introspective delicacy of the writing and the particular acting relationship shared by Oliver, Lane and Kirke. (Kirke is especially conspicuous in some charged scenes towards the end.) I’m not quite sure where Alwyn fits into that picture; too often, his man-of-few-words routine reads like monotony.

He is convincing in the sex scenes, at least, which is perhaps why a portion of this show’s viewers will tune in. I like it Normal people before that, conversations with friends he frequently turns away from his navel to delight in the release of bodily communion. Those scenes are especially vital here, as they are the most expressive the two leads ever get to be. But this is not exactly erotic. The sex is narratively instructive, advancing Frances’s journey rather than stopping for a mere transcendent date.

Still, as exhilarating as those scenes may be, conversations with friends spends much of its midsection in a drift. A trip to a beautiful seaside house in Croatia livens up the setting (oh, how drab Dublin is on this show), but the characters remain caught up in their little eddies. The repetitive tug-of-war of Frances and Nick’s mix may be familiar to those who’ve experienced something similar, all that longing at constant war with practical doubt, but as entertainment, it’s exhausting.

There is the payoff of the last two episodes of the series, at least, in which Rooney’s thesis is presented and we feel a surge of aching nostalgia for our own wobbly-legged first steps into the adult world, both laborious and reckless. This is, perhaps, an announcement of the experience of reading the novel, in which Frances can speak louder than ever on the screen.

Leave a Comment